CCM Documentation Checklist: What Medicare Auditors Check
Updated November 2026. Written by Matteo Grassi, clinical psychologist and cofounder of HANA Health.
CCM documentation is the set of records in a patient's chart that proves each chronic care management claim met Medicare's rules: two or more qualifying chronic conditions, documented consent, a comprehensive care plan, an initiating visit when required, and enough clinical staff time to reach the billed code. In March 2026 the HHS Office of Inspector General opened a national audit of CCM payments focused on the multiple chronic conditions requirement.
Having sat on both sides of a patient phone call, I'll say it plainly: the call is the easy part. The note that proves the call happened is where programs get into trouble.
Key facts
- Active audit: OIG announced audit OAS-26-09-007 on 16 March 2026 to review CCM payments at risk of not meeting the multiple chronic conditions requirement (HHS OIG Work Plan, 2026).
- First audit: For 2015 and 2016, OIG found $640,452 in CCM overpayments on 20,165 claims (HHS OIG, A-07-17-05101, 2019).
- Second audit: For 2017 and 2018, OIG found $1,918,278 in overpayments on 50,192 claims, most of them the same CCM service billed twice for the same patient and month (HHS OIG, A-07-19-05122, 2021).
- Consent: Verbal or written consent is allowed, but five specific elements must be explained and documented in the record (CMS MLN909188, June 2025).
- Oversight: CMS says that if a billing practitioner provides little oversight of a third party delivering CCM, the practice shouldn't bill for it (CMS CCM FAQs, 2022).
- Overpayments: Once identified, an overpayment must be reported and returned within 60 days, with a suspension of up to 180 days for a timely, good faith investigation (42 CFR 401.305).
Why are auditors looking at CCM documentation now?
Because CCM has grown fast and the paper trail hasn't always kept up. OIG's 2026 Work Plan entry says Medicare Part B payments for CCM "increased substantially" from 2019 through 2024, and it names one requirement as the audit focus: whether patients really have multiple qualifying chronic conditions.
This isn't OIG's first look. Its 2019 report reviewed every paid CCM claim from 2015 and 2016, about $103.5 million, and its 2021 report covered more than 7.8 million physician claims from 2017 and 2018. Both found the same pattern: duplicate billing for the same patient and month, and CCM billed alongside overlapping care management services. In 2021 OIG reported that 17,120 of the duplicate claims involved more than one practitioner billing the same patient.
Enforcement has also moved beyond audits. In April 2026, a Florida physician and practice agreed to a five year exclusion after OIG alleged they billed CCM codes 99490, 99439, 99487 and 99489 for services they didn't render (HHS OIG enforcement action, 2026).
The lesson for a practice is simple. CMS told OIG it has since added claim edits, but edits can't see what's missing from a chart. Auditors can.
What must the chart show to prove CCM eligibility?
The chart has to show two or more chronic conditions, each expected to last at least 12 months or until death, that place the patient at significant risk of death, acute exacerbation or decompensation, or functional decline. Listing two diagnosis codes isn't the same as showing that risk.
CGS, the Medicare contractor for Jurisdiction 15, asks practices to make sure the record supports that the patient is at significant risk of death, acute exacerbation or decompensation, or functional decline because of the chronic conditions (CGS J15 CCM guide).
In practice that means a short clinical statement for each qualifying condition: what it is, why it's expected to last, and what risk it carries for this patient. "Type 2 diabetes with an A1c trending up and two missed refills last quarter" tells an auditor far more than an ICD code sitting alone in the problem list.
Since OIG has named this requirement as its audit focus, it's the first thing to check in your own sample.
What does the CCM documentation checklist include?
Here's a month by month checklist built from the CMS booklet, the CMS FAQs and Medicare contractor guidance. Each item maps to a requirement an auditor can test.
- Initiating visit: for new patients or patients not seen in the previous year, a face to face E/M visit, AWV or IPPE where CCM was discussed. If CCM wasn't discussed, the visit doesn't count.
- Eligibility narrative: two or more qualifying chronic conditions, with duration and risk documented.
- Consent: written or verbal, documented once unless the patient switches practitioners, covering availability of CCM, possible cost sharing, that only one practitioner can bill CCM in a month, the right to stop at the end of any month, and whether the patient accepted.
- Structured data: demographics, problems, medications and medication allergies recorded in certified EHR technology.
- Comprehensive care plan: problem list, measurable treatment goals, expected outcome and prognosis, symptom management, planned interventions, medication management, coordination with outside providers, and a schedule for review. A copy goes to the patient or caregiver.
- Time: clinical staff or practitioner time for the month, recorded as start and stop times or total time, reaching at least 20 minutes for 99490 or 60 minutes for 99487.
- Services rendered: what was done in each contact, by whom, and how it ties to the care plan.
- Practitioner involvement: evidence of oversight by the billing practitioner, and for complex CCM, moderate or high complexity medical decision making during the month.
If an item is missing, the claim is exposed. If two are missing, the month probably shouldn't have been billed.
How should CCM time be documented?
CCM time should be recorded per contact, by a named clinical staff member or practitioner, with start and stop times or a total, and with a note of what was done. CGS states that time should be clearly documented as either start and stop time or total time.
Only clinical staff time counts toward 99490, 99439, 99487 and 99489, and only when Medicare's incident to rules are met, according to the CMS CCM FAQs. Scheduling, mailing and other administrative work can support the program but can't be counted. CPT 99491 and 99437 count only time the billing practitioner personally spends.
Three habits make time logs hold up:
- Log at the time of the activity. A month end reconstruction looks like one, and it reads that way to a reviewer.
- Tie minutes to the plan. "12 minutes: reviewed home glucose log with patient, adjusted follow up per care plan goal 2" survives an audit. "12 minutes: CCM call" doesn't.
- Watch the overlap. Time spent during a face to face visit that's billed separately shouldn't also be counted as CCM time.
Can an outside vendor's records cover the practice in an audit?
No. The claim is the practice's claim, so the practice owns the documentation, even when outside clinical staff do the work. CMS allows the clinical staff portion of CCM to come from staff external to the practice if every incident to rule and other billing rule is met.
CMS also draws a hard line. Its FAQs say that if there's little oversight by the billing practitioner, or a lack of clinical integration with a third party, CCM isn't really being furnished and the practitioner shouldn't bill. The billing practitioner's oversight work can't be delegated or subcontracted, and CCM can't be billed when the person delivering it is located outside the United States.
So a vendor's call log isn't enough on its own. The practice's chart should show the care plan the practitioner owns, the practitioner's review, and notes that make sense to someone who's never heard of the vendor. We've covered the staffing rules in more detail in can outside staff deliver CCM, and the question of automated work in whether AI agent time counts toward CCM minutes.
What this means for your practice
Start with a small internal audit before anyone else runs one. Pull 10 to 20 CCM months across your billing practitioners and test each one against the checklist above, with eligibility first, since that's where OIG says it's looking.
Then check for the errors OIG has found twice: a second CCM biller for the same patient, and CCM billed with an overlapping care management service in the same month. Our guide to which care management codes can be billed in the same month walks through the combinations.
If the sample turns up claims that shouldn't have been paid, talk to your compliance lead or counsel promptly. Under 42 CFR 401.305 the 60 day clock starts when the overpayment is identified, the deadline can be suspended for up to 180 days during a timely, good faith investigation, and the lookback period is six years.
Finally, fix the template rather than the individual note. A consent script with all five elements, a care plan template with measurable goals, and a time field that forces a description will do more than any one off cleanup. If you're new to the program, our CCM pillar guide and CCM consent and care plan requirements cover the basics.
HANA Health builds voice agents that support care management programs between visits, with every contact written back for the care team to review. You can see how that works on the HANA Remote page.
Frequently asked questions
Does a CCM consent have to be written?
No. Medicare accepts verbal or written consent. What matters is that the record shows the five required elements were explained and whether the patient accepted or declined.
How often does a patient need to give CCM consent?
Once, according to the CMS booklet, unless the patient switches to a different CCM practitioner. It's still good practice to document a patient's later decision to stop, which takes effect at the end of the calendar month.
Does the care plan need a physician signature?
The CMS booklet and the CMS FAQs don't list a signature requirement for the care plan. They do require a comprehensive, electronic plan that's created, revised and monitored, and shared with the patient or caregiver, so check your contractor's guidance and your own policies.
What happens if a CCM audit finds overpayments?
The Medicare contractor decides whether overpayments exist and recovers them, and providers can appeal. In both CCM audits, OIG also recommended that CMS have providers refund the cost sharing patients paid on overpaid claims, so the copay is part of the exposure too.
Is the OIG CCM audit finished?
Not as of this update. The 2026 Work Plan lists project OAS-26-09-007 as active, with no completion date shown.
Sources
- HHS Office of Inspector General. Audit of Medicare Payments for Chronic Care Management Services at Risk of Noncompliance, OAS-26-09-007. 2026. oig.hhs.gov
- HHS Office of Inspector General. Medicare Made Hundreds of Thousands of Dollars in Overpayments for Chronic Care Management Services, A-07-17-05101. 2019. oig.hhs.gov
- HHS Office of Inspector General. Medicare Continues To Make Overpayments for Chronic Care Management Services, A-07-19-05122. 2021. oig.hhs.gov
- HHS Office of Inspector General. Enforcement action: exclusion for chronic care management claims not rendered. 2026. oig.hhs.gov
- CMS Medicare Learning Network. Chronic Care Management Services, MLN909188. June 2025. cms.gov
- CMS. Frequently Asked Questions About Practitioner Billing for Chronic Care Management Services. 2022. cms.gov
- CGS Administrators. Chronic Care Management (CCM), J15. 2022. cgsmedicare.com
- Electronic Code of Federal Regulations. 42 CFR 401.305, Requirements for reporting and returning of overpayments. Amended 2024. ecfr.gov
This article is educational and isn't billing, coding, clinical or legal advice. Check current CMS guidance and your MAC before you bill. If you'd like to talk through your care management program, book a call with me.
